JeremyG3289 Says:

Oct 3, 2006 - Do you have "Daisy" that you can upload....Comment back in my profile....Thanks

RitchieBrown123 Says:

Oct 21, 2006 - Is this George Carlin? Also, I think they should've used the Brick Bridge before Maron in this episode.

Miketheredengine Says:

Jan 1, 2007 - I have the UK version

1f5sda Says:

Apr 5, 2007 - It is George Carlin.

icysonicx Says:

Apr 22, 2007 - i dont like uk version

discovery995 Says:

May 5, 2007 - I Think carlin did the better narration for season 1 and ringo did the better narration for season 2

hungryjokester Says:

Jun 16, 2007 - He did narrate this, but it got replace with thomas comes to breakfast for some unknown reason(possibly taken epsidoes from order when shining time air them,curse them).

hungryjokester Says:

Jun 30, 2007 - What I meant was that ringo narrated this episode for the U.S., but it's not seen yet.

magicbird05 Says:

Jul 2, 2007 - Trust me,he didn't. If he did,it would have showed up on Shining Time Station,and a Thomas video by now.

hungryjokester Says:

Jul 30, 2007 - You have a good point, but some people said they saw episodes like donald & douglas, the deputation, daisy, percy's predicament, etc. in 2007 on television on some kids channel.

magicbird05 Says:

Aug 7, 2007 - Well,they are wrong

EdwardTheBlueEngine2 Says:

Aug 10, 2007 - Actually,i saw season 2 eposodes this year on tv

jordanschepis Says:

Aug 11, 2007 - what channel

EdwardTheBlueEngine2 Says:

Aug 11, 2007 - no idea to be honest

jordanschepis Says:

Aug 12, 2007 - ok then

hungryjokester Says:

Aug 16, 2007 - EdwardTheBlueEngine2, when did you see season 2 episodes on t.v. and what network was it on?

magicbird05 Says:

Aug 17, 2007 - LOL he's lying didn't you see he said "no idea".

BigThomasFan Says:

Aug 21, 2007 - Actually, they're right. PBS Kids Sprout shows all the classic Thomas episodes (with George Carlin, though).

EdwardTheBlueEngine2 Says:

Sep 2, 2007 - I ment "No idea why i should be honest and tell you".

MistaMeltonio Says:

Sep 27, 2007 - i love carlin's ACHOO!

blainethomas Says:

Oct 19, 2007 - originally on a rare video: Daisy. P.S. THIS SHOULD'VE BEEN TOLD BY RINGO IN THE US! :(

hungryjokester Says:

Oct 20, 2007 - I agree with you. I think Starr's US narration was originally going to be on the Tenders and Turntables. Perhaps there was a mistake with shining time station when they first thomas!

hungryjokester Says:

Oct 30, 2007 - I didn't know that Ringo Starr episodes were on PBS Kids Sprout. Can someone please tell me which season 1 and 2 episodes had Ringo's narration?

magicbird05 Says:

Oct 31, 2007 - He never did PBS sprout,George Carlin narrarated them

Xwingpilot Says:

May 26, 2008 - I don't know about you guys but I think I do like George Carlin's rarration in this episode better than Ringo Starr's. Especially how he does Henry's sneezing.